The Asian turtle crisis: why freshwater turtles and tortoises are disappearing
Asia's freshwater turtles and tortoises are among the most threatened animals on Earth. We explain the trade behind the crisis, the plight of box turtles and the debate over turtle farms.

Turtles have been around since the time of the dinosaurs. Yet in the space of a few decades, many of Asia's freshwater turtles and tortoises have been pushed to the edge of extinction. Conservationists use the phrase "the Asian turtle crisis" to describe what happened: an enormous and largely unregulated trade that moved millions of wild turtles from forests, streams and rice fields across Asia into markets, restaurants and pet shops.
This article explains why turtles are so easily overharvested, what drives the trade, why box turtles such as the Chinese three-striped box turtle have been hit especially hard, and why turtle farming has not been the solution many hoped it would be.
Why turtles cannot withstand heavy collection
Turtles have a life history that works well in nature but makes them extremely vulnerable to human harvest. Many species take years to reach breeding age, lay relatively few eggs each year, and lose most of their eggs and hatchlings to predators. Populations stay stable because adults live a long time and keep breeding for decades.
That strategy collapses when people remove adults. A population that loses its breeding adults cannot replace them quickly, and the decline can continue long after collecting stops. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, in a 2013 briefing on Asian turtles, noted that over 75% of the more than 90 turtle species found in Asia were considered threatened, and described a "boom and bust" pattern in which traders move from one species to the next as each becomes too scarce to supply demand or too tightly regulated to trade easily.
Globally, the picture is also grim. A 2018 report by the Turtle Conservation Coalition found that more than half of the world's turtle and tortoise species were threatened, and that Asian species made up the largest share of its list of the 50 most endangered.
What drives the trade: food, medicine and pets
The crisis is driven by several overlapping kinds of demand.
- Food. Turtles have long been eaten in parts of East and Southeast Asia, and some dishes are associated with good health or special occasions. As demand grew, it outstripped what local wild populations could supply, and traders increasingly sourced animals from other countries in the region.
- Traditional medicine. Turtle shells and other parts are used in some traditional remedies. For certain rare species, beliefs about medicinal value, which are not supported by scientific evidence, have made individual animals extraordinarily valuable.
- Pets and collectors. Rare turtles are prized by hobbyists in Asia, Europe and North America. As a species becomes scarcer, its price can rise, which gives poachers even more reason to search out the last individuals.
These markets are linked to the wider illegal wildlife trade, and live turtles are often transported in crowded, unsanitary conditions alongside other animals, a concern explored in our article on wildlife markets and public health.
Box turtles: the hardest hit
Asian box turtles belong to the genus Cuora. They get their name from a hinged lower shell that allows some species to close up almost completely. Their striking colors and patterns have made them targets for collectors, and several species are now assessed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List.
The Chinese three-striped box turtle
The Chinese three-striped box turtle (Cuora trifasciata), often called the golden coin turtle (金钱龟), is native to southern China, including Hong Kong and Hainan. (Related turtles from Vietnam and Laos are now usually treated as a separate species.) It is assessed as Critically Endangered by the IUCN. According to Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden (KFBG) in Hong Kong, hunting has pushed the species close to extinction across its range. The turtle is valued as a symbol of good luck and prosperity and is used in traditional medicine, though claims that it can cure cancer are unsubstantiated.
As wild numbers fell, prices rose, which in turn encouraged more poaching. KFBG describes the protected countryside of Hong Kong as one of the species' last chances of surviving in nature, with a small breeding population persisting in remote valleys and streams. Conservation groups there work with the government to protect these refuges and run captive breeding for rescued animals.
The story of this one turtle illustrates the wider crisis: scarcity does not reduce demand for a luxury or prestige product. It can make each remaining animal more valuable.
Farming versus wild collection
Turtle farming is often presented as a way to relieve pressure on wild populations. In theory, if farms can supply the market, there is less reason to catch turtles from the wild. In practice, the evidence is mixed.
China has a very large turtle-farming industry. A study published in the journal Oryx in 2008, based on a survey carried out in 2002, contacted the 1,499 officially recognized turtle farms in China. The 684 farms that responded reported selling more than 300 million turtles a year, worth around US$750 million, mostly the Chinese softshell turtle. The authors argued that the true scale was larger, since most farms did not respond and some operate covertly.
The researchers also raised serious concerns:
- Farming can make the trade harder to monitor, because market surveys cannot easily tell farmed animals from wild-caught ones.
- Whether farms replenish their breeding stock with animals taken from the wild remained an unresolved question.
- The overall effect of the industry on wild species was likely to be serious, even if hard to measure.
The authors concluded that, rather than relying on captive breeding, conservation should focus on protecting wild turtles in natural areas. Farming common species such as softshell turtles for food is a very different matter from breeding rare box turtles, and it does not answer the problem of poaching rare species from the wild.
Trade controls and the law
International trade in many Asian turtles is regulated under CITES, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora. At the CITES conference in Bangkok in March 2013, governments adopted proposals led by the United States, two of them co-sponsored by China, to increase protection for 44 species of Asian freshwater turtles and tortoises. These measures included adding species to Appendix II, which requires permits showing that trade is legal and not harmful to wild populations, and setting zero quotas for commercial trade in wild-caught animals of some species.
Within China, many native turtles, including box turtles, are protected by national law. Our article on China's Wildlife Protection Law explains how species are listed and what protection means in practice. Laws only work, however, when buyers stop creating demand and when enforcement is supported by public awareness.
What you can do
- Do not buy wild turtles or turtle products. If you cannot be sure an animal or product is legal and from a sustainable source, do not buy it.
- Think carefully before keeping any turtle as a pet. Turtles can live for decades and need specialist care.
- Never release pet turtles into the wild. Released pets can compete with native turtles and spread disease. Our article on red-eared sliders and invasive pets explains why.
- Report suspected illegal sales of protected turtles to the local forestry and wildlife authorities.
- Protect turtle habitat. Clean streams, undisturbed wetlands and intact forests are where wild turtles have the best chance of recovery.
The Asian turtle crisis is not yet over, but it is not hopeless. Where habitats are protected, collecting is controlled and buyers turn away, turtle populations have a chance to recover.
References
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, "U.S. Cosponsors Proposals with China and Viet Nam to Increase CITES Protections for 44 Species of Asian Freshwater Turtles" (CoP16 fact sheet), 2013. https://www.fws.gov/sites/default/files/documents/news-attached-files/cop16-asian-turtle-proposals-factsheet.pdf
- Mongabay, "Turtles win greater protection at CITES meeting", 2013. https://news.mongabay.com/2013/03/turtles-win-greater-protection-at-cites-meeting/
- Mongabay, "New report highlights top 50 tortoises and turtles on brink of extinction", 2018. https://news.mongabay.com/2018/03/new-report-highlights-top-50-tortoises-and-turtles-on-brink-of-extinction/
- Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden, "Golden Coin Turtle". https://kfbg.org/en/fauna-conservation/golden-coin-turtle
- Fong J. et al., "Cuora trifasciata", The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, 2020. https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/123768950/123769768
- Shi H., Parham J.F., Fan Z., Hong M. and Yin F., "Evidence for the massive scale of turtle farming in China", Oryx 42(1), 2008. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605308000562
